Blog

Payment Orchestration vs Payment Service Providers: A comprehensive guide to optimizing your payment strategy

In the rapidly evolving world of digital payments, businesses face mounting pressure to provide secure, seamless, and cost-effective payment experiences.

The rise of e-commerce, mobile apps, and global transactions has increased expectations for businesses to accept a wide variety of payment methods. As businesses scale, they often encounter challenges in managing these diverse payment methods and ensuring efficient payment processing.

Two essential components in the payment ecosystem are Payment Service Providers (PSPs) and Payment Orchestration Platforms (POPs). While both are designed to facilitate online payments, they differ significantly in their approach and capabilities. In this comprehensive guide, we will dive into the differences between these two solutions, exploring their features, benefits, limitations, and how each can help businesses optimize their payment strategy.

What is a Payment Service Provider?

A Payment Service Provider (PSP) is a third-party service that helps businesses accept electronic payments.

PSPs serve as the connection between merchants, customers, and payment networks, including credit card companies, banks, and alternative payment methods (APMs).

By partnering with a PSP, merchants can quickly start accepting various payment methods – such as debit and credit cards, e-wallets, and even bank transfers – without needing to establish individual relationships with banks or processors.

PSPs have been a cornerstone in simplifying payment processing for businesses of all sizes. They typically offer a full suite of services, including payment authorization, fraud prevention, and settlement, all of which are essential to keeping transactions secure and compliant with regulations like PCI DSS.

How Does a Payment Service Provider Work?

Key Advantages:

Simple Integration: PSPs offer a single integration point for merchants to accept a wide variety of payment methods, which simplifies the setup process and reduces technical complexity.

Compliance and Security: PSPs manage security protocols such as encryption, tokenization, and fraud prevention, ensuring compliance with regulations like PCI DSS, which protects sensitive data during transactions.

Pre-integrated Payment Methods: PSPs provide businesses with an array of pre-integrated payment methods, which saves time and reduces the need for merchants to handle separate integrations for each payment type.

Limitations:

Lack of Flexibility: PSPs often work within a fixed infrastructure, meaning businesses have limited ability to customize payment routing and may not have access to the most cost-effective payment solutions.

Vendor Lock-in: Once businesses establish a relationship with a PSP, switching to another provider can be difficult, often requiring a new integration or changes to their payment infrastructure.

Regional Limitations: Some PSPs offer limited coverage in certain geographic regions, which can be a challenge for businesses operating globally and requiring access to local payment methods.

What is a Payment Orchestration Platform?

Payment Orchestration Platforms (POPs) are a more advanced solution for businesses looking to optimize their payment processing.

Unlike PSPs, which act as a single provider handling all payment processes, POPs integrate multiple payment providers into a single platform, allowing businesses to manage and optimize payments through multiple gateways, acquirers, and payment service providers.

Essentially, a POP acts as a "hub" that connects businesses to various payment providers, enabling greater flexibility, optimization, and scalability.

POPs offer advanced functionality by managing multiple payment methods and processors in real-time. They route transactions based on factors such as cost, performance, customer location, and transaction type. This dynamic decision-making ensures that businesses can provide the most efficient and cost-effective payment options to their customers.

How Does a Payment Orchestration Platform Work?

Payment Orchestration Platforms combine several payment-related services into one integrated solution, allowing businesses to optimize their payment infrastructure without having to rely on a single provider. Here’s an overview of how a POP typically operates:

Key Benefits:

Dynamic Payment Routing: POPs use intelligent algorithms to route payments to the most cost-effective and reliable provider, ensuring better conversion rates and lower transaction fees.

Customizable Payment Experience: POPs allow businesses to present different payment methods based on factors like geography, device type, or customer preferences, ensuring a personalized and seamless experience.

Global Scalability: POPs can easily integrate local payment methods when businesses expand into new markets, providing greater flexibility and scalability for global operations.

Advanced Analytics and Reporting: POPs offer detailed insights into payment performance, helping businesses make data-driven decisions to optimize their payment strategies.

Reduced Payment Failures: With features like cascading and retry logic, POPs automatically reroute transactions that fail, reducing the chances of abandoned purchases and lost revenue.

While both PSPs and Payment Orchestration Platforms facilitate online payments, they are fundamentally different in how they operate and what they offer businesses.

Scope of Functionality
- PSPs: A PSP is a single, standalone service provider that handles payment processing. It handles all aspects of payment transactions, from authorization to settlement.
- POPs: In contrast, a POP is an integrated solution that connects businesses to multiple payment providers, enabling them to route payments dynamically and optimize their payment flows.
Flexibility and Control
- PSPs: With a PSP, businesses are typically limited to a fixed payment flow and may only be able to integrate the payment methods and providers supported by the PSP. This lack of flexibility can be restrictive, especially as businesses scale.
- POPs: POPs offer greater control over payment routing, allowing businesses to dynamically route payments based on predefined rules. They can also integrate a wide variety of payment providers and methods, providing more options and flexibility.
Cost Optimization
- PSPs: PSPs often have a fixed pricing model based on transaction fees, which can be less cost-effective for businesses with large or international operations. Additionally, businesses cannot easily switch to cheaper providers without significant effort.
- POPs: By enabling dynamic routing and allowing businesses to choose the most cost-effective payment processors for each transaction, POPs help businesses minimize fees and optimize their payment processing costs.
Scalability
- PSPs: As businesses grow, they may need to use multiple PSPs to support different payment methods or expand into new markets. This can lead to complex integrations and higher maintenance costs.
- POPs: Payment Orchestration Platforms are designed for scalability, allowing businesses to integrate new payment providers and methods with minimal effort. This makes it easier to expand into new markets and manage global payments.

The Benefits of using Payment Orchestration with Payment Service Providers

While a Payment Orchestration Platform offers advanced functionality and flexibility, it does not replace the need for a PSP. Instead, it complements the PSP by enhancing its capabilities and optimizing payment performance. By integrating a POP with an existing PSP, businesses can leverage the strengths of both solutions.

Here’s how businesses can benefit from combining a POP and a PSP:

Enhanced Customer Experience: By offering a wider range of payment methods and presenting the most relevant options to each customer, businesses can create a seamless and personalized checkout experience.
Cost Efficiency: With intelligent routing and the ability to switch between providers based on cost, businesses can optimize payment processing fees, reduce transaction costs, and maximize revenue.
Improved Payment Success Rates: Payment Orchestration Platforms can reduce payment failures by automatically rerouting failed transactions to secondary providers or alternative payment methods, ensuring that customers can complete their purchases.
Streamlined Operations: POPs consolidate payment management, reducing the complexity of dealing with multiple providers. This saves time, resources, and administrative costs.

01
Operate
- the best payment ecosystem for your market
02
Customize
- Payment methods in any digital channel
03
Boost
- conversion rates and eliminate payment friction
04
Optimise
- performance through real-time monitoring

The Airline Industry’s Shift to Payment Orchestration

The airline industry is a prime example of how Payment Orchestration can revolutionize payment processing. With millions of transactions taking place daily, airlines face numerous challenges in managing global payments, offering local payment methods, and ensuring smooth transactions across various channels.

Airlines that have integrated Payment Orchestration Platforms have reported a significant increase in payment approval rates, reduced transaction fees, and improved customer satisfaction.

By leveraging dynamic routing, airlines can ensure that payments are processed through the most reliable and cost-effective channels, enhancing both profitability and customer experience.

Conclusion

Choosing the Right Payment Solution for Your Business

As businesses continue to expand their digital presence, selecting the right payment solution becomes increasingly important.

Both Payment Service Providers (PSPs) and Payment Orchestration Platforms (POPs) offer valuable services, but they cater to different business needs.

PSPs are ideal for businesses with simple payment processing requirements, while Payment Orchestration Platforms provide more flexibility, optimization, and scalability for businesses with complex, global payment needs.

By understanding the unique benefits of each solution, businesses can create a comprehensive payment strategy that supports their growth and enhances the customer experience. Whether you choose a PSP, a POP, or a combination of both, the key to success is adopting a solution that aligns with your business goals and enables you to stay competitive in the ever-changing digital economy.